Recently, I’ve found more tantalizing and interesting books in the office of my frontlist children’s book buyer than in the office of the adult book buyer. Now this isn’t because of my lack of maturity or low reading ability. I fault the large amount of quality literature being written there. Twilight (in all its poorly written melodrama) wasn’t just a fad; there is some seriously good writing here. Last fall, I devoured Mockingbird by Erskine. It put its adult contemporary (?) The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night Time to shame.
Seriously.
There is a reason all your friends are telling you about The Hunger Games and it isn’t for the gratuitous violence. Or because you have a freakish obsession with Battle Royale. It’s solid. It’s what we remember our writing teachers pushing down our throats: It’s a good story; not an overpowering narrator (first, second, or third) holding your hand and telling you the story. Any successful book (adult or juvenile) will show you the story, will give you flawed characters who develop as the pages progress, will offer you up insight into your being for your subconscious to munch on during your REM cycles. The Hunger Games does that. Mockingbird won the National Book Award because it did that. Divergent by Veronica Roth blew the top off the dystopian craze Suzanne Collins started; Divergent, in my opinion, is the only book that holds a candle to The Hunger Games or vice versa.So I offer for your reading pleasure a short list of books you should be reading. And while you cruise over my reviews, think about this small quote from W. Bruce Cameron (A Dog’s Purpose):
I look at the popularity of YA novels–Harry Potter, the Hunger Games series, etc.–and wonder why more authors don’t write books that can be read by the whole family, why we have to employ a whole separate category to keep young readers segregated. There’s nothing wrong with adult-themed books–I read them all the time–but often I’ll remember that fourth grader reading The Caine Mutiny, and ruefully reflect that there just aren’t that many novelists confident enough in their work to avoid shoving gratuitous sex, language and violence into a few scenes just to make sure adults are titillated.
Divergent by Veronica Roth
Our society has ended. And from the ashes comes five different factions–each with their own air-tight theory on how society should be run. Amity believes that through peace society will succeed. Candor believes truth is the only way. Erudites feel intelligence, research, and science will lead to a perfect society. Dauntless hold to bravery as the only option. And Abnegation demonstrate that selflessness is the best choice. Sounds like a hoot, right?
Born into an Abnegation family, Beatrice just doesn’t seem to fit into the faction’s beliefs. So when her chance to change her fate arises, she chooses Dauntless, those fun-loving daredevil folks who would never give up their seat on the bus or take the stairs or wear gray the shade of cloudy days. Beatrice renames and re-brands herself as Tris, first among the Dauntless initiates. She skates through the different levels of initiation, trying to overcome the nickname “Stiff”, and trying to prove that a member of Dauntless is nothing like a member of Abnegation.
Trouble is… Bravery isn’t too far from selflessness when one really looks at it.
Written with more weight than most of the YA dystopian novels out there, Divergent isn’t about one girl who can’t choose between boys while her society tumbles down around her. It’s about a girl who happens to find herself as her society tumbles down around her. Sure, there is some romance, but Tris stays true to herself and doesn’t falter a bit once she has made up her mind. Not wimpy or weepy in the slightest. (If you need an example of wimpy weepy girl, let me know; I’ve got the impression down.)
Wither by Lauren DeStefano
At Winter Institute, I had the pleasure of sitting at a Children’s book buyer table during lunch. And nearly every publisher had “The Next Twilight”, at least that is what the rep from Simon & Schuster said as she told us about Wither, Book One of the Chemical Garden trilogy.
Imagine a world where we have created a perfect generation of children: no childhood diseases, no cancer, no illness at all. Perfect, right? But as that perfect generation heads healthily toward old age, it is discovered that our meddling has some repercussions; the children of this perfect generation die early. Very early–females at 20, males at 25.
And because of this, a division in society occurs. One faction fights to return things to a natural order, let us re-evolve out of this bed we made. The other faction believes an answer might be found scientifically, so girls are stolen from their homes, sold into marriage, forced (as much as one can be forced) to have children, and then they die.
Between these to factions, one finds the main character of the series, Rhine, a 16 year old girl taken from her twin brother in NYC and sold to a boy, Linden (21), to be one of his three wives. Linden’s father is a member of the First Generation (that perfect crowd), and he has designs on the young women and the children they might yield.
Despite Linden’s true feelings for Rhine, she falls for a servant (adding an interesting finite love triangle) to the story. The lines of good and bad are seriously smudged in this first book; and it leaves one ready to pick up the next.
Crossed by Ally Condie
It is my literary theory that the second book in any series is about walking. Just look at “The Two Towers” by Tolkien–it’s ALL walking; it’s actually quite amazing a movie was able to be adapted from that schlepping-fest.
“Crossed” does not deviate from this norm. The action is quite literally the characters walking from one end of a canyon to the other and then back in again and then out back again, ad nauseum. However, walking does have a benefit beyond aerobic: it allows for character development. Where “Matched” endeared Cassia to the reader and began to create her as a three-dimensional being, “Crossed” completes Cassia’s character and begins to
build up Ky, one of the two sympathetic male characters in Cassia’s world. The walking also affords time for the reader to understand the world the characters live in.
After being separated at the end of the first novel, Cassia and Ky quickly are reunited after some minor challenges and some personal growth. The chapters jump back and forth between Cassia and Ky, so the reader is giving an eye on the movements of each character. This narrator flip helps give depth to the characters and also serves the purpose of dialogue for most of the book as Cassia and Ky don’t do much talking.
While the Society is more acutely explained in this novel and the threat of the Society discovering the main characters looms, it truly doesn’t play a large part in most of the story. Much like an evil Godot–never showing up. So despite moments of mini-action, there isn’t much going on besides the internal monologue of two teenagers, who believe (for the most part) they are madly in love.
And like any good mid-series book, “Crossed” answers some questions, but leads to more. I suspect there are enough fans of the first book to read the second, but be warned that it doesn’t have the happy (?) climax of the first book; “Crossed” seriously drops off the narrative right as the action starts. Don’t take this as a negative review; I’m impatiently waiting for the next serving in this series.
***********
I’ve a couple more reviews in my bag, but I think these three are a good selection of the dystopian young adult wave.
Tune in next week when I finally finish my two cents on e-books, and why owning a kindle is much like being a smoker to this single girl.
July 13th, 2011 at 1:15 am







